Random Quote: "The artist is the phoenix who burns to emerge." -Janet Fitch

"I totally agree with you and I'm going to be critical too. First of all the guy playing Ethan is way too short in the book Ethan is around 6 feet. Then he looks too old for a sixteen year old. Second of all Lena has to have this beautiful black…"

"I really wonder how she got her powers back (if she really did; I`m still doubtful)...and poor Link, I agree. I kind of do like Liv though. I got a little hateful when Ethan called her "L", but you can`t blame him; he was pretty…"

"I highly doubt that they would kill off Ethan.  I think Lena will try to save him but might end up going completely Dark in order to bring him back along with his fractured soul.  I don't think he will become a Caster because that is…"

"But no one has thought about Ryan. If Lena is such a powerful natural who's to say Ryan isn't a just as powerful healer? Together they might be able to bring Ethan back to life, maybe if everyone works together they can save him. The book…"

"I agree, but I dont think Link could bite him. Isnt Ethan practically a spirit now, which means he`s not tangible or physical ? I think Lena might e sacrificing something again to bring him back. "

"The book is beautiful redemption so something has to be redeemeed, like Ethans life? And by putting Ethans two halves together then his purpose was served, he can come back to life. I agree that he should probably come back as a castor thing, but if…"

"I HATED the way the book ended, but I think he`s not exactly dead. I think he`s like his mother: still able to communicate with the mortal and caster world. & of course, he and Lena are going to find some way to be together again (which means…"

"This series is great but i bet you if ethan does die they might have to go to abraham and sarafine to make him come back but he will also be a caster maybe a"

"i was upset too hate the ending basically everything else the ending"

"I thought it was great but my girlfriend ruin the end for me so i didn't bother finishing off but i agree with sydney duchannes he has got to live."

"I loved it can't wait for the next book!!!! :D"

"obviously Ethan doesn't die other wise why would they be making Beautiful Redemption ? I mean they could switch the point of view from Ethan to Lena but then it probably wouldn't be as good as all the others."

" "

"I loves the book the end wasnt disappointing because I know it's not the true end it has given enough to hold me over until beautiful redemption comes out and everything really come to an end and then I will have the movie an then I will be out…"

"How do we know that there is a forth book? I was only thinking Lena - Ninteen Moons."